Jun 29, 2018 09:36
5 yrs ago
1 viewer *
Russian term

художник - не от слова «худо»

Russian to English Other Other
Послушай, братишка, художник - не от слова «худо»! Надо стараться и много учиться - тогда непременно выйдет толк.

Discussion

El oso Jul 1, 2018:
painting is not just about pain alone. That's definitely more like it!
А еще говорят? что от перестановки мест слагаемых сумма не меняется.. Еще как меняется! ;)
Andrew Vdovin (asker) Jul 1, 2018:
Всем спасибо за предложенные варианты. Что касается painter и pain - мне кажется, здесь как раз нужно не противоставлять, а сравнивать: To be a good painter, you have to take pains... - что-нибудь вроде этого.
The Misha Jun 30, 2018:
It really depends on what you do with that play on words. You see, little brother, painting is not just about pain alone. If you do your best and work hard, you'll get there - i budet tebe shchastye:)

Incidentally, this is also true. I should know, I oil-paint myself even though I have absolutely no idea how and what the heck it is I am doing. But I get by.
El oso Jun 30, 2018:
@ IrinaN Ага! Теперь понятно откуда коллеге пришла идея про "painter и "pain"! :)
Turdimurod Rakhmanov Jun 30, 2018:
RE:nothing to do with "pain" I completely agree with this "nothing to do with pain", because the play on words is the best way of rendering here. However, I would like to point out that:
Russian word "Художник" does not mean "Painter" in this context. Painter=живописец, which is one of the special genres of Art. But "Художник" creates his works not only with paints, the term "Художник" covers more than "paint". Art and Artist is a broader and clear term in this case.
IrinaN Jun 29, 2018:
Very interesting question And two entirely different approaches to the meaning of pain. There is an attempt to play with "pain" here: https://phraseology_ru_en.academic.ru/29688/художник_от_слов... with the suggestion that pain here means pain and suffering for those who are forced to look at such art. In any case, pain has something to do with pain.
El oso Jun 29, 2018:
RE:nothing to do with "pain" I've got to say, I am somewhat surprised to see a heavyweight like Misha throwing his weight behind this option :) Yes, I suppose, you could argue that the play on words there is good (excellent, even), except it has nothing to do with the premise of the original, as I see it. I think everyone here will agree that being an artist (or any other professional for that matter) DOES "have to do with pain", because being a professional involves hard, PAINstaking work, no matter what you are: an artist, a pianist or a soccer player. See my point? And notice that even the original goes on to say "you have to work hard and learn a lot of things, only then will you be successful''. I mean, how could you possibly marry hard work and intensive learning process with "nothing to do with pain"? It just makes no sense.

I'm sorry I had to ruin your Black Panther party, guys (c) ;)
Turdimurod Rakhmanov Jun 29, 2018:
Painter vs Artist Здесь сначала уточнить Panter или Artist, как мне кажется здесь не painter а, artist.
Turdimurod Rakhmanov Jun 29, 2018:
I think, you want English equivalent here?
Version:
Look here, my buddy (bro), Artist is not of the word "Arte" (or "Artel" or "*art", "artless"), too many options.

Proposed translations

+1
9 hrs
Selected

тоже от обратного

… Listen, bro, a true art walks hand in hand with back-breaking work; you must strive and study hard not to be a disappointment.




--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 11 hrs (2018-06-29 20:39:40 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

Or, for good measure

... there are painters and there are house-painters
Peer comment(s):

agree Maksym Nevzorov
18 hrs
Спасибо!
Something went wrong...
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer. Comment: "Thank you very much for your help Irina! Thanks everybody!!!"
+1
41 mins

Art is not for the faint-hearted

I don't think anything like a literal translation is possible. But put this in the context as given, and it makes sense, conveying the intention of the original.
Peer comment(s):

agree Gwain Hamilton
4 hrs
Thank you.
Something went wrong...
45 mins

Art(s) is not playing cards

Arts is not playing cards

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 57 mins (2018-06-29 10:33:29 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

Arts is not like "playing cards"
здесь в значении: Arts (искусство изобр)- это не игрушка, или игра, надо серьезно воспринимать

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 1 hr (2018-06-29 11:10:16 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

OR:
Art is not a playing card.
Something went wrong...
+2
3 hrs

it actually takes skill to be..

Look, kid, (I hate to disappoint you, but) it actually takes skill to be an artist.
Or:
Look, kid, (this may come as a bit of a shock to you, but) it actually takes (a certain amount of) skill(s) to be an artist.
То есть идем от обратного.

PS: Раз уж Джек сказал что дословный перевод здесь невозможен, то куда уж нам простым смертным (читай "не нейтивам") ;)
Peer comment(s):

agree IrinaN : With logic and strategy, but something bugs me, likely the belittling implication that the kid is worthless, and we don't know that. The stress should be on hard work even for the most talented.
6 hrs
Спасибо! Однако, похоже что моя логика только Вас впечатлила :) И братишка не worthless, а излишне самоуверенный, кмк. Говорящий же пытается вернуть его не землю, так сказать.
agree Maksym Nevzorov
1 day 1 hr
Спасибо!
Something went wrong...
+5
20 mins

painter, nothing to do with "pain"

OR an artist, well to do with Art

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 11 hrs (2018-06-29 21:31:31 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

All Art and no pain makes Jack a good boy!

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 1 day 22 hrs (2018-07-01 08:28:16 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

согласен, но только без painter, на него у народа зуб:-)
All pain and no art makes a dull artist!

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 2 days 7 hrs (2018-07-01 17:08:29 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

painter is not only an artist who paints pictures, the creature paints fences & houses too, the main translator's pain in such case...
Note from asker:
А может, наоборот: "to be a good painter, you have to take pains"?
Peer comment(s):

agree Maria Kaverina
1 min
Thank you very much, Maria!
agree The Misha : For once, I find myself agreeing with you. This was my own first impulse too, except this really needs to be worked into the sentence.
4 hrs
Thank you so much, The!
agree Natalia Potashnik
4 hrs
Thank you very much, Natalia!
agree Sarah McDowell
13 hrs
Thank you very much, Sarah!
agree Mark Vaintroub : Хороший вопрос и очень хороший ответ!
1 day 7 hrs
Thank you, Mark! I dare answer your question too.
Something went wrong...
Term search
  • All of ProZ.com
  • Term search
  • Jobs
  • Forums
  • Multiple search